Growth Investing vs Value Investing: Which one is right for you?

Growth Investing vs Value Investing: Which one is right for you?

April 21, 2021 | 21025 Views

There is simply no doubt that investing is done by investors everywhere to create wealth by earning profits. While there have been many investing styles & strategies that have made headlines or are mentioned every now and then, two investment styles stand out due to their popularity and effectiveness ie Growth investing & Value investing. Although both these types are basically fundamental in their approach, they possess their own sets of merits & demerits.

Investors often measure both these styles of investing against each other to discover which of these they can adopt to maximize their profits. The pandemic has only amplified this question further.

We believe that the real question investors need to adopt is not just that but also which of these two investing styles is equipped to perform during the prevailing economic conditions. After all, businesses & the stock market are heavily dependent on the economy.

It is age-old wisdom that value stocks outperform growth stocks over the long run. However, it is important to note that growth has been outperforming value for roughly a decade now!

Let us understand the difference between Value investing and Growth investing first.

Value Investing

Simply put, Value investors look out for hidden gems that they perceive to be low priced compared to their intrinsic value. The reason could be anything from a short term event like a few bad quarters or a long term phenomenon like a depressed industry or sector.

Value stocks are believed to be underpriced either within a specific industry or the market more broadly. Investors buy such stocks hoping that the price will rebound once others catch on. Generally speaking, these stocks have low price-to-earnings ratios and high dividend yields. There is always the risk that the price may not appreciate as expected, especially if the stock belongs to a poor quality company that has fallen out of business due to unethical reasons.

For instance, DLF has often been considered a value buy, but its returns have hardly measured up to the hype especially for ultra long term investors.

DLF Ltd chart (2008-2020)

DLF Ltd

However, other renowned value buys like L&T & Sun Pharma have generated decent returns over the years.

L&T Ltd chart (2006-2021)

L&T Ltd

Sun Pharmaceuticals Ltd chart (2006-2021)

Sun Pharmaceuticals Ltd

Benjamin Graham is known as the father of value investing & arguably one of the most famous investors, Warren Buffet is also known for his value investing style. However, that does not mean that he doesn’t invest in growth stocks. His Portfolios boast of profitable growth stocks such as Snowflake, Moody’s, Costco, American Express, Visa, Apple, Amazon, Mastercard, Synchrony Financial & so on.

Growth Investing

Growth investors usually seek out young, early-stage companies that are seeing rapid growth in profits, revenue or cash flow. Such stocks are also known as Multibaggers & are actively sought out by investors seeking to build substantial wealth.

Growth stocks represent companies that have demonstrated better-than-average gains in earnings in recent years and are expected to continue delivering high levels of profit growth. Typically, these companies are leaders in their respective industries and are higher priced than the broader market. They also tend to be more volatile & the risk in buying a given growth stock is that its price could fall sharply on any negative news about the company, particularly if its earnings disappoint the investor expectations.

One infamous growth stock that has displayed quality growth but also increased volatility during recent times is Bajaj Finance Ltd.

Bajaj Finance Ltd Chart (2016-2021)

Bajaj Finance Ltd

Other growth stocks which have generated multifold returns over the years include HUL, Nestle & Asian paints.

Hindustan Unilever Limited Chart (2006-2021)

Hindustan Unilever Limited

Nestle Ltd Chart (2011-2021)

Nestle Ltd

Asian Paints Ltd Chart (2006-2021)

Asian Paints Ltd

This style’s father, Thomas Rowe Price Jr. developed this philosophy in the 1930s and later went on to create the asset management firm that still bears his name: T. Rowe Price. Most of the new-age industries like Technology & IT tend to consist of growth stocks and are actively sought after by savvy investors.

Value Investing Vs Growth Investing

Investing styles Price P/E ratio Dividends Risk
Value stocks Perceived to be undervalued Generally low Generally high dividend yields May not appreciate as much
Growth stocks Perceived to be Overvalued Generally above average Generally low or no dividend yields Chances of relatively high volatility

The below table indicates the earnings growth P/E or P/B expansion of the mentioned Value & Growth Stocks:

Company name 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Growth
Asian Paints P/E 43x 55x 48x 53x 53x 66x 59x
EPS 12.71 14.54 18.19 20.22 21.26 22.48 28.2
Nestle P/E 52x 99x 58x 62x 67x 72x 70x
EPS 122.87 58.42 103.85 127 166.6 204.2 215.9
HUL P/E 33x 43x 45x 44x 55x 60x 74x
EPS 18.24 20.17 19.2 20.72 24.14 28.03 31.24
Bajaj Finance P/B 2.2x 4.3x 5.1x 6.7x 6.5x 8.9x 4.1x
EPS 14.45 17.96 23.88 33.58 43.4 69.26 87.74
BV 80.2 95.9 136.7 175.5 274.1 339.1 535.2
Value
Sun Pharma P/E 38x 47x 43x 24x 57x 43x 22x
EPS 15.17 21.92 18.89 29.03 8.73 11.11 15.69
DLF P/E 49x 52x 67x 37x 8x 33x
EPS 3.63 3.03 1.72 4.01 25.02 5.98 -2.36
L&T P/E 24x 34x 27x 24x 25x 22x 12x
EPS 35.26 24.17 30.29 43.17 52.59 63.48 68.02
NIFTY 17,853.20 0.17% SENSEX 60,048.47 0.27% BANKNIFTY 37,830.30 0.16% ADANIPORTS 744.80 -1.29% ASIANPAINT 3,448.60 3.85% AXISBANK 798.05 -1.74% BAJAJ-AUTO 3,809.80 0.28% BAJAJFINSV 18,526.00 0.12% BAJFINANCE 7,793.40 -1.34% BHARTIARTL 739.40 1.73% BPCL 414.80 -1.23% BRITANNIA 4,042.90 0.01% CIPLA 967.65 -0.05% COALINDIA 166.10 -0.75% DRREDDY 4,790.35 -0.14% EICHERMOT 2,931.00 2.59% GAIL 152.60 -0.20% GRASIM 1,629.75 1.43% HCLTECH 1,358.20 2.25% HDFC 2,839.00 0.77% HDFCBANK 1,601.55 2.01% HEROMOTOCO 2,833.45 -0.69% HINDALCO 478.75 -0.93% HINDUNILVR 2,746.65 -1.28% IBULHSGFIN 225.85 -1.65% ICICIBANK 722.95 0.83% INDUSINDBK 1,163.05 -0.52% INDUSTOWER 317.65 13.83% INFY 1,763.85 1.22% IOC 117.25 -0.64% ITC 238.45 -1.67% JSWSTEEL 659.15 -2.67% KOTAKBANK 2,028.10 0.20% LT 1,768.75 -0.05% M&M 779.45 2.77% MARUTI 6,952.25 1.54% NTPC 124.25 -1.55% ONGC 136.10 -1.20% POWERGRID 176.15 -1.18% RELIANCE 2,482.70 -0.29% SBIN 440.75 -2.01% SUNPHARMA 770.45 0.08% TATAMOTORS 317.95 -1.10% TATASTEEL 1,272.10 -3.53% TCS 3,871.30 0.05% TECHM 1,514.75 -0.44% TITAN 2,092.90 -0.58% ULTRACEMCO 7,521.50 -1.29% UPL 718.65 -1.13% VEDL 293.10 -2.17% WIPRO 676.50 0.33% YESBANK 12.85 -1.15% ZEEL 318.90 0.22%